Rhetorical Pronouns: Point
of View
Dale Larson
Grays Harbor College
Uses of "I"
-
"I" as the writer alone, speaking
out of personal experience to illustrate, usually, some personal opinion
("The idea is particularly useful. I, for example, have . . . ").
-
"I" as a representative of or
spokesperson for a group, often used after formal, rhetorical questions
("What does this country and this party need?" "I suggest . . . ,
" "I answer . . . ," "I declare . . . ").
-
"I" as a hypothetical substitute
for "one" ("When I refuse to obey an unjust law, I do not contest the right
of the majority to command": Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy
in America).
-
"I" as an impersonal guide in
formal exposition or argument, used to retard a quick line of thought ("This
idea is in theory simple, I submit, but in practice, difficult")
-- sometimes to order a long, complex logical/rhetorical form ("I
have explicitly argued that . . . ," "I have earlier suggested that . .
. ").
Uses of "We"
-
"We" as a familiar rhetorical
agent including the writer and reader ("We must, of course, both agree").
-
"We" as a spokesperson for a
group, "the editorial we" ("We endorse the [Daily World's, Newsweek's,
Rolling
Stone's] view").
-
"We" as a representative of
a group -- possibly excluding the reader's ("We Harborites," "We Americans,"
"We Christians").
-
"We" as all humankind ("We're
all doomed").
Uses of "One"
-
"One" as representing either
the writer or reader ("Understanding as much, one should see that . . .").
-
"One" as a cleverly disguised
"I," though used with an "I" for formal emphasis or variety ("I agree,
of course, but one wonders if the 'ayes' could still have it").
-
In British English: "One wonders
when one is British if one is living one's life rather too formally?"
Uses of "You"
-
"You" as one's individual reader
in letters or in exposition in understood form ("Consider the notion
that . . . , " "Take the case of . . . ," "Notice the implication
that . . . ").
-
"You" as a vague indefinite
reference used together with "we" for informal, even ironic emphasis or
variety (T. S. Eliot, "Tradition and the Individual Talent":
"In English writing we seldom speak of tradition . . . You can hardly
make the word agreeable to English ears without . . . comfortable reference
to the reassuring science of archaeology").